Reviewer ID Number    Manuscript Number    Date 

SSMJ Manuscript Review Form

Please provide specific information about strengths and weaknesses for each criterion. Finally, make your recommendation for acceptance. Note: This review will be furnished to the author(s).

Strengths and Weaknesses

Criterion Strengths Weaknesses
 Problem/Research questions
 Theoretical framework/Literature review
 Design/Instrumentation/Procedure
 Data analysis/Results
 Discussion/Conclusions
 Written Presentation/Style
 Adds new knowledge

Additional comments


Recommendation

 Accept with revisions  Revise and resubmit  Reject

Please submit your review or reset to clear



 

Thank you